BagAlert.appNever Miss a TooGoodToGo Bag in New York City
1,700
Active Stores
4.5★
Avg Rating
252,358
Reviews
Bakery
Top Category
Explore New York City by Neighborhood
Get hyper-local with neighborhood-specific store lists and insights
Top Rated Stores
Discover the best TooGoodToGo locations based on ratings and reviews
Stew Leonard's Farm Fresh Food & Wine
★ 4.8(1,117 reviews)
Chip City
★ 4.8(996 reviews)
Chip City
★ 4.8(1,021 reviews)
Breads Bakery
★ 4.7(1,107 reviews)
Chip City
★ 4.8(887 reviews)
Pullman Bakery & Shige Pan
★ 4.6(1,118 reviews)
Chip City
★ 4.8(868 reviews)
Chip City
★ 4.8(836 reviews)
Northside Bakery
★ 4.8(799 reviews)
Popular Categories in New York City
Bakery (830)Restaurant (826)Other (293)Grocery (206)
Local Tips for New York City
Insider knowledge to maximize your success
- 💡NYC is bagel heaven - Manhasset Bagels (4.95★), Knead A Bagel (4.94★), and Knickerbocker Bagel (4.93★) are must-follows
- 💡Chip City has 6 NYC locations all rated 4.80+ stars - reliable for gourmet cookie bags
- 💡NYC is EXTREMELY competitive: 1,208 stores have 100+ reviews. Alerts are essential - bags sell out in 2-5 minutes
- 💡Restaurant bags dominate NYC at 40% of listings - more meal options than any other city
- 💡Breads Bakery operates 3 Manhattan locations with 3,000+ combined reviews - iconic NYC bakery
- 💡Average savings: $6.17 → $18.52 (66.7% off) - better discount percentage than Toronto despite lower prices
Frequently Asked Questions
Everything you need to know about TooGoodToGo in New York City
How many TooGoodToGo stores are in New York City?▼
There are currently 1,700 active stores in New York City, with an average rating of 4.5 stars across 252,358 customer reviews.
What are the best-rated TooGoodToGo stores in New York City?▼
Top-rated stores include Stew Leonard's Farm Fresh Food & Wine, Chip City, Chip City. Stew Leonard's Farm Fresh Food & Wine is particularly popular with 1,117 reviews and a 4.8-star rating.
What types of food can I find in New York City?▼
New York City offers 4 different food categories. The most common are Bakery, Restaurant, Other, with Bakery being the most popular.
Which store has the most reviews in New York City?▼
AB Fish Market & Food is the most reviewed with 1,345 customer reviews, making it one of the most active locations in New York City.
How many TooGoodToGo stores are in New York City?▼
NYC has 2,465 active TooGoodToGo stores across all 5 boroughs, with over 335,000 customer reviews - the highest engagement of any North American city. With 153 average reviews per store, NYC is the most competitive TooGoodToGo market globally.
What are the best-rated TooGoodToGo stores in NYC?▼
NYC's bagel shops dominate: Manhasset Bagels (4.95★), Knead A Bagel (4.94★), and Knickerbocker Bagel (4.93★) are top-rated. For bakeries, Pain D'Avignon (4.85★, 813 reviews) and Breads Bakery (multiple locations, 3,000+ combined reviews) are favorites. AB Fish Market leads with 1,345 reviews.
Why is NYC known for bagel surprise bags?▼
NYC has the strongest bagel culture on TooGoodToGo - the top 5 highest-rated stores are all bagel shops. With shops like Manhasset Bagels (4.95★), Knead A Bagel (4.94★), and dozens of other authentic NYC bagel delis, you'll find fresh bagels, schmear, and breakfast sandwiches at 70% off retail.
How much can I save with TooGoodToGo in NYC?▼
NYC bags average $6.17 for items valued at $18.52 - saving $12.35 per bag (66.7% discount). While slightly cheaper than Toronto, NYC offers better percentage savings. Premium bags from stores like AB Fish Market can exceed $150 in value.
How competitive is TooGoodToGo in New York City?▼
Extremely competitive. NYC has 1,208 stores with 100+ reviews each - the most saturated market globally. Popular Manhattan spots like Bibble & Sip (1,256 reviews) and Breads Bakery sell out within 2-5 minutes. Instant alerts are essential to succeed in NYC.
Which chains have multiple NYC locations on TooGoodToGo?▼
Chip City (gourmet cookies) operates 6 NYC locations, all rated 4.80-4.83 stars. Breads Bakery has 3 Manhattan locations with 3,000+ combined reviews. Just Salad has multiple FiDi locations. These chains list consistently and are great for reliable bags.
What types of food are most common in NYC?▼
NYC is restaurant-heavy: 40% of bags are full meals (highest in North America), including Italian, Asian, fish markets, and quick-service chains. Bakeries account for 37.4% with world-class options. NYC has more meal variety than any other TooGoodToGo market.
Is BagAlert affiliated with TooGoodToGo?▼
No, BagAlert is an independent tool. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Too Good To Go.
Ready to Start Saving in New York City?
Join thousands of users getting instant alerts for surprise bags
Get Started FreeAlso Serving
Disclaimer: BagAlert is an independent service and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Too Good To Go. TooGoodToGo and related trademarks are the property of their respective owners.